Tier List

Christmas Movies Tier List: All 34 Films Ranked (2026)

The best Christmas movie is It's a Wonderful Life (1946), with Home Alone, Elf and Klaus right behind it in S tier. Here are 34 Christmas movies ranked from S-tier to D-tier, from 1946 to 2024, with the rating, runtime and family picks for every one.

The Complete Christmas Movies Tier List

  • It's a Wonderful Life (1946)
  • Home Alone (1990)
  • Elf (2003)
  • The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992)
  • Klaus (2019)
  • The Nightmare Before Christmas (1993)
See the A to D tiers (28 more films)
  • A Christmas Story (1983)
  • National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation (1989)
  • Die Hard (1988)
  • Love Actually (2003)
  • Miracle on 34th Street (1947)
  • The Holdovers (2023)
  • Gremlins (1984)
  • Arthur Christmas (2011)
  • White Christmas (1954)
  • Scrooged (1988)
  • The Holiday (2006)
  • Home Alone 2: Lost in New York (1992)
  • How the Grinch Stole Christmas (2000)
  • The Polar Express (2004)
  • Bad Santa (2003)
  • Black Christmas (1974)
  • Violent Night (2022)
  • The Santa Clause (1994)
  • Krampus (2015)
  • The Grinch (2018)
  • A Christmas Carol (2009)
  • Happiest Season (2020)
  • Last Christmas (2019)
  • The Night Before (2015)
  • The Family Stone (2005)
  • The Best Christmas Pageant Ever (2024)
  • Jingle All the Way (1996)
  • Red One (2024)
The whole list at a glance. Tap a poster to read why it sits there.

Rank Christmas your way

Our top 5, head-to-head. Tap the one you prefer and we will build your order, then show you where you disagree with us.

VS

Or rank all 34 Christmas films in the app

Or rank our top 10 here, in your browser

Each film below also says where to watch it in the US, checked November 16, 2026 (JustWatch). Rights move, so those lines disappear rather than guess once that check is over three weeks old.

S

It's a Wonderful Life

(1946)

Frank Capra and James Stewart, and an angel who shows George Bailey what his town would look like if he had never been born. It is far darker than its reputation, which is exactly why the last ten minutes work. TMDB users rate it the highest Christmas movie there is.

Streaming on Prime Video, Paramount+ and Peacock

Home Alone

(1990)

Kevin McCallister is left behind when his family flies to Paris, and turns the house into a booby-trapped fortress against two burglars. John Hughes wrote it, Chris Columbus directed it, and it is the most-rated Christmas movie on TMDB by a margin.

Streaming on Disney+

Elf

(2003)

Will Ferrell plays a human raised at the North Pole who travels to New York to find his father. Jon Favreau keeps it earnest, which is the trick: Buddy is never the joke, everyone around him is. The modern Christmas comedy every other one gets measured against.

Streaming on Prime Video and HBO Max

The Muppet Christmas Carol

(1992)

Michael Caine plays Scrooge completely straight while Gonzo narrates as Charles Dickens, and that one decision makes it the most faithful screen version of the story. Paul Williams wrote the songs.

Streaming on Disney+

Klaus

(2019)

A spoiled postman is exiled to a frozen island town and, by accident, invents Santa Claus. Netflix's hand-drawn origin story was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Animated Feature, and it is the newest film on this list to earn an S.

Streaming on Netflix

The Nightmare Before Christmas

(1993)

Jack Skellington, the king of Halloween Town, discovers Christmas and decides to run it himself. Henry Selick's stop-motion and Danny Elfman's songs hold up completely. Is it a Halloween movie or a Christmas movie? It is both, and it is the shortest film here.

Streaming on Disney+

The Reel

One sharp movie newsletter, every Tuesday

What to watch, what to skip, and where it lands on the rankings. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Just want the tier sheet? Download it free, no email needed.

A

A Christmas Story

(1983)

Ralphie wants a Red Ryder BB gun, and every adult tells him he will shoot his eye out. Bob Clark's episodic, narrated look back at a 1940s Indiana Christmas is built from small moments (the leg lamp, the flagpole, the bunny suit) rather than a plot.

Streaming on HBO Max

National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation

(1989)

Clark Griswold wants the perfect family Christmas and gets 25,000 lights that will not turn on, a dried-out tree and Cousin Eddie's RV in the driveway. Written by John Hughes, it is the best of the Vacation films and the one people actually rewatch every year.

Streaming on HBO Max

Die Hard

(1988)

John McClane flies to Los Angeles to see his wife at her office Christmas party and ends up alone against Hans Gruber's crew in Nakatomi Plaza. Yes, it is on this list: it is set on Christmas Eve, it is about a family coming back together, and it ends with Let It Snow over the credits.

Streaming on Prime Video and Hulu

Love Actually

(2003)

Richard Curtis braids about ten London love stories across the five weeks before Christmas. Some strands have aged badly and some are perfect (Emma Thompson and the Joni Mitchell CD is the best scene in it).

Streaming on Netflix and Peacock

Miracle on 34th Street

(1947)

A Macy's Santa insists he is the real Kris Kringle, and it ends up in court. Edmund Gwenn won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor for the role, and the film still beats every remake of it.

Streaming on Prime Video and Disney+

The Holdovers

(2023)

A disliked teacher, a troubled student and the school's grieving cook are stuck together at a New England boarding school over Christmas break in 1970. Alexander Payne and Paul Giamatti, and Da'Vine Joy Randolph won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actress. The best Christmas film of the 2020s so far.

Streaming on Peacock

Gremlins

(1984)

Three rules for a Christmas present: no bright light, no water, and never feed it after midnight. Joe Dante breaks all three in a snowed-in small town, and the result is half creature feature, half pitch-black holiday comedy.

Streaming on HBO Max

Arthur Christmas

(2011)

Santa's operation is a high-tech military mission now, and one child's present has been missed. Aardman's comedy sends Santa's clumsy younger son to deliver it by hand before sunrise. The most underrated animated Christmas film there is.

Rent or buy only

Disagree with our order?

Rank all 34 Christmas films yourself in Shortlist, two at a time, and keep your own tier list. Free on iPhone and Android.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
B

White Christmas

(1954)

Bing Crosby and Danny Kaye put on a show to save their old general's failing Vermont inn, with Rosemary Clooney and Vera-Ellen and a full Irving Berlin songbook. Thin as a story, lovely as a musical.

Streaming on Prime Video and Paramount+

Scrooged

(1988)

Bill Murray as a TV executive staging A Christmas Carol live on Christmas Eve while three ghosts stage one on him. Messy and mean for most of its running time, then Murray's closing speech earns it.

Streaming on Prime Video and Paramount+

The Holiday

(2006)

Cameron Diaz and Kate Winslet swap houses, Los Angeles for a Surrey cottage, for the two weeks around Christmas. Nancy Meyers comfort viewing, with Jude Law and Jack Black, and the longest film on this list by a minute.

Streaming on Hulu

Home Alone 2: Lost in New York

(1992)

The same film again, in New York, with the Plaza Hotel and Tim Curry. Every beat of the original repeated a size bigger, and the traps are cruel enough to wince at. Still the third most-rated Christmas movie on TMDB.

Streaming on Disney+

How the Grinch Stole Christmas

(2000)

Ron Howard's live-action Whoville, with Jim Carrey under Rick Baker's Academy Award-winning makeup. Carrey is a lot, and that is the film: you are either in on it or you are not.

Streaming on Peacock

The Polar Express

(2004)

A boy who has stopped believing boards a train to the North Pole. Robert Zemeckis made it in motion capture, with Tom Hanks in several roles, and the faces still sit in the uncanny valley. The train sequences are spectacular; the people are the problem.

Streaming on HBO Max

Bad Santa

(2003)

Billy Bob Thornton as a drunk, foul-mouthed safecracker who works as a mall Santa every December to rob the store. Terry Zwigoff's film is genuinely nasty, and it is also the most honest Christmas comedy here about loneliness.

Streaming on Prime Video and Paramount+

Black Christmas

(1974)

A sorority house over Christmas break, obscene phone calls, and a killer who is already inside. Bob Clark's slasher came four years before Halloween, and Clark went on to direct A Christmas Story nine years later.

Streaming on Prime Video, Peacock and Fandor

Violent Night

(2022)

David Harbour plays a burned-out Santa who drops down the chimney of a rich family's compound in the middle of a hostage raid. It is Die Hard with a sleigh, and it knows it. Gleefully gory.

Streaming on Netflix

C

The Santa Clause

(1994)

Tim Allen's divorced dad puts on the suit after Santa falls off his roof and, by the fine print, becomes Santa. A clever premise with a lot of 1994 sitcom on top of it.

Streaming on Disney+

Krampus

(2015)

A family that cannot stand each other loses its Christmas spirit, and the Alpine anti-Santa comes to collect. Michael Dougherty's horror comedy has great creature work and a tone that never quite settles.

Streaming on Prime Video and Peacock

The Grinch

(2018)

Illumination's animated version, with Benedict Cumberbatch as a Grinch who is mostly just lonely. Bright, gentle and very young-skewing: a fine first Grinch for a small child, and a forgettable one for everyone else.

Streaming on Peacock

A Christmas Carol

(2009)

Robert Zemeckis's second motion-capture Christmas film, with Jim Carrey as Scrooge and all three ghosts. Faithful to Dickens and genuinely frightening in places, but the roller-coaster camera fights the story.

Streaming on Prime Video and Disney+

Happiest Season

(2020)

Kristen Stewart goes home for Christmas with her girlfriend (Mackenzie Davis), who has not come out to her family. Clea DuVall's Hulu premiere has a terrific supporting cast and Dan Levy, and a central romance plenty of viewers argue with.

Streaming on Hulu

Last Christmas

(2019)

Emilia Clarke as a London Christmas-shop elf whose life is falling apart until Henry Golding appears. Emma Thompson co-wrote it around George Michael's songs, and the twist is either moving or ridiculous depending on who you ask.

Streaming on Hulu

The Night Before

(2015)

Seth Rogen, Joseph Gordon-Levitt and Anthony Mackie spend one last Christmas Eve chasing a legendary New York party. Loose and very funny in stretches, with Michael Shannon as the best drug dealer in any holiday movie.

Streaming on Starz

The Family Stone

(2005)

Sarah Jessica Parker meets her boyfriend's close, judgmental family over Christmas, with Diane Keaton as the mother. A family dramedy that swerves hard between cringe comedy and real grief.

Streaming on Prime Video and Hulu

The Best Christmas Pageant Ever

(2024)

The six wildest kids in town take over the church Christmas pageant. A sweet, small adaptation of Barbara Robinson's 1972 book, and the least-rated film here on TMDB, so its score is the least settled on the list.

Streaming on Netflix

D

Jingle All the Way

(1996)

Arnold Schwarzenegger as a dad hunting the sold-out Turbo-Man toy on Christmas Eve. A satire of holiday shopping that turns into the thing it is satirising. The lowest TMDB score on the list.

Streaming on Prime Video, Disney+ and Hulu

Red One

(2024)

Santa is kidnapped, and Dwayne Johnson and Chris Evans have to get him back. A streaming-sized action franchise idea with a theatrical release: loud, expensive-looking and with none of the warmth that puts films higher on this list.

Streaming on Prime Video

Your turn

That is our Christmas ranking. Here is a blank one for yours.

All 34 Christmas films, one tap each, S down to D. It saves as you go and it prints. No email, no signup.

Open your Christmas tier sheet

Every film here is a feature set at Christmas that reached theaters or premiered on a streaming service; TV specials like A Charlie Brown Christmas are a different list. The 2000s give the list the most entries, 8 films, and the oldest is It's a Wonderful Life from 1946. Think Love Actually belongs in S tier, or Die Hard does not belong here at all? Settle it yourself with Shortlist.

Every Christmas Movie by Year, Rating and Runtime

All 34 films run 59h 20m back to back; the six S-tier films alone run 9h 50m, one long Christmas Eve. TMDB users rate It's a Wonderful Life highest at 8.3, ahead of Klaus at 8.2, and Home Alone is the most-rated, with 13,070 votes.

FilmRatedRuntimeTierTMDB
It's a Wonderful Life1946PG131 minS8.3
Miracle on 34th Street1947NR96 minA7.4
White Christmas1954NR120 minB7.2
Black Christmas1974R98 minB7.0
A Christmas Story1983PG93 minA7.2
Gremlins1984PG106 minA7.1
Die Hard1988R132 minA7.8
Scrooged1988PG-13101 minB6.8
National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation1989PG-1397 minA7.2
Home Alone1990PG103 minS7.5
Home Alone 2: Lost in New York1992PG120 minB6.8
The Muppet Christmas Carol1992G86 minS7.5
The Nightmare Before Christmas1993PG76 minS7.9
The Santa Clause1994PG97 minC6.5
Jingle All the Way1996PG89 minD6.1
How the Grinch Stole Christmas2000PG105 minB6.8
Bad Santa2003R92 minB6.6
Elf2003PG97 minS6.7
Love Actually2003R135 minA7.1
The Polar Express2004G100 minB6.7
The Family Stone2005PG-13103 minC6.3
The Holiday2006PG-13136 minB7.1
A Christmas Carol2009PG96 minC6.9
Arthur Christmas2011PG97 minA6.8
Krampus2015PG-1398 minC6.2
The Night Before2015R101 minC6.1
The Grinch2018PG85 minC6.9
Klaus2019PG97 minS8.2
Last Christmas2019PG-13103 minC7.2
Happiest Season2020PG-13102 minC7.1
Violent Night2022R112 minB7.2
The Holdovers2023R133 minA7.7
Red One2024PG-13124 minD6.9
The Best Christmas Pageant Ever2024PG99 minC6.8

US certifications, runtimes and TMDB user scores (out of 10) read from the TMDB API on 2026-11-15, by film id. NR films were released before the MPAA ratings system existed. The tier is this list's editorial call, not the score.

The Best Christmas Movies for Kids and Families

17 of the 34 films here are rated G or PG, and 9 of those sit in S or A tier: It's a Wonderful Life, Home Alone, Elf, The Muppet Christmas Carol, Klaus, The Nightmare Before Christmas, A Christmas Story, Gremlins and Arthur Christmas. For younger children, The Muppet Christmas Carol and The Polar Express are the two rated G. Gremlins is rated PG but was one of the two 1984 films that pushed the MPAA to create PG-13, so treat it as a teenager's pick.

The other end: 7 films are rated R, from Black Christmas in 1974 to The Holdovers in 2023, and Bad Santa and Violent Night are the two to keep away from the kids' table.

Is Die Hard a Christmas Movie?

Yes, and it is ranked here in A tier. The whole film takes place on Christmas Eve at an office Christmas party, John McClane's reason for being there is to win his family back for the holiday, and it ends with Let It Snow playing over the credits. It is also the second most-rated film on this list, with 12,868 TMDB votes, and the best-rated R-rated one at 7.8. If you disagree, that is the point of a tier list: move it.

How to Build Your Own Christmas Tier List

The card above ranks every film from your taps alone, one head-to-head pick at a time, no scoring. Most people agree on the top two or three. Where Love Actually, The Holiday and Die Hard land is where the family arguments start.

The app is for everything after that. Shortlist runs the same head-to-head across whatever you watch, keeps each list current as you rewatch every December, and gives every ranking a share link for the group chat.

Read more about the comparison-based approach in our movie tier list guide, or rank the animated classics in our Disney movies ranked list.

Two different things get scored around this page. The S to D tiers above are editorial, and S means a film that held up rather than one that reviewed well on opening weekend. The score you see in the app is a different number: it is built from the head-to-head comparisons you make, scaled to 0 to 10, not from critic averages. How Shortlist scores work sets out the whole method.

This website uses TMDB and the TMDB APIs but is not endorsed, certified, or otherwise approved by TMDB.

Christmas Movies Tier List FAQ

What is the best Christmas movie of all time?

It's a Wonderful Life (1946) is the best Christmas movie of all time, and it is also the one TMDB users rate highest: 8.3 from 5,166 votes. It tops an S tier of six with Home Alone, Elf, The Muppet Christmas Carol, Klaus and The Nightmare Before Christmas.

Is Die Hard a Christmas movie?

Yes. Die Hard (1988) takes place entirely on Christmas Eve at an office Christmas party, and John McClane is there to win his family back for the holiday. It is ranked in A tier on this list of 34 Christmas movies, and it is the best-rated R-rated film on it.

What is the most popular Christmas movie?

Home Alone (1990) is the most-rated Christmas movie on TMDB, with 13,070 votes, just ahead of Die Hard. Its sequel, Home Alone 2: Lost in New York, is third.

What are the best Christmas movies for kids?

17 of the 34 films on this list are rated G or PG. The best of them for families are Home Alone, Elf, The Muppet Christmas Carol, Klaus, The Nightmare Before Christmas, A Christmas Story and Arthur Christmas. At the other end, 7 are rated R, including Bad Santa and Violent Night.

How long does it take to watch every Christmas movie on this list?

All 34 Christmas movies here run 59h 20m back to back. The six S-tier films alone take one long Christmas Eve, and the shortest film on the list is The Nightmare Before Christmas at 76 minutes.

Why is A Charlie Brown Christmas not on the list?

This list ranks feature films only: movies that reached theaters or premiered on a streaming service. A Charlie Brown Christmas, Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer and the 1966 animated How the Grinch Stole Christmas! are TV specials, so they are left off on purpose. The 2000 live-action How the Grinch Stole Christmas and the 2018 animated The Grinch are both ranked.

Related Tier Lists

Your turn

Rank our top 10 Christmas films yourself

Pick between two at a time and get your own tier list in about a minute. Free, in your browser, no signup.

Start ranking

Rather do it on paper? Download the tier sheet, free.

Rank the Christmas movies your way

Download Shortlist and build your own Christmas movie tier list with head-to-head comparisons. It's free.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play