ReviewNovember 19, 20266 min read

Sunrise on the Reaping Is Certified Fresh at 72 Percent. Critics Agree on Joseph Zada and Argue About Everything Else.

The Haymitch prequel opens Friday ranked third of six Hunger Games films on Rotten Tomatoes and fifth on Metacritic. Here is why the two scores disagree, what nearly every review praises, and where critics split.

Joseph Zada as a young Haymitch Abernathy kneels among bright pink and purple flower beds in the arena of The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, beside another tribute
Image via The Movie Database (TMDB)

The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens everywhere on Friday, and the reviews have had two days to settle. As of Thursday morning, Francis Lawrence's Haymitch prequel holds 72 percent on Rotten Tomatoes from 107 reviews and carries the Certified Fresh badge. On Metacritic it sits at 55 from 32 critics, which the site labels mixed or average.

Those two numbers tell different stories, and the reviews behind them explain why.

The scorecard

  • Rotten Tomatoes: 72 percent from 107 reviews (77 fresh, 30 rotten), with an average rating of 6.7 out of 10. It opened at 69 percent from 62 reviews when the embargo lifted on Tuesday and has crept up since.
  • Metacritic: 55 from 32 critics, with 16 positive, 14 mixed and 2 negative reviews.
  • Audiences: no Popcornmeter yet, and CinemaScore polls opening-night crowds on Friday.
  • The basics: rated PG-13 and 2 hours 38 minutes, the longest film in the series, adapted by Billy Ray and Michael Lesslie from Suzanne Collins' 2025 novel about the 50th Hunger Games.

Make your tier list right here

Five Hunger Games films, head-to-head. Tap the one you prefer and we will build your order, then label it S through D.

Which do you prefer?

VS

Tap your favorite

Third of six on Rotten Tomatoes, fifth on Metacritic

Line up all six films by Tomatometer and Sunrise on the Reaping lands right behind the two that started it all:

  1. Catching Fire (2013): 90 percent, Metascore 76
  2. The Hunger Games (2012): 85 percent, Metascore 68
  3. Sunrise on the Reaping (2026): 72 percent, Metascore 55
  4. Mockingjay Part 1 (2014): 70 percent, Metascore 64
  5. Mockingjay Part 2 (2015): 70 percent, Metascore 65
  6. The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes (2023): 64 percent, Metascore 54

Sort by Metascore instead and it falls to fifth, one point ahead of Ballad. The gap comes from how the sites count and who they count. Rotten Tomatoes only asks whether a review is positive. Metacritic turns each review from a smaller pool of publications into a 0 to 100 grade and averages them, so a shrug and a rave do not weigh the same.

This movie has a lot of shrugs that still count as fresh. Variety's Owen Gleiberman called it "meandering and more than a bit thin," and his review still counts as fresh. The fair summary: most critics liked it, and fewer than you would guess from the badge loved it.

Theatrical poster for The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping
Image via TMDB

The Reel

Get this in your inbox every Tuesday

You are reading The Reel, Shortlist's weekly movie brief. One email a week, free, unsubscribe in one click.

The one thing critics agree on: Joseph Zada

Woody Harrelson's funny, wrecked mentor was one of the best things about the original films, so recasting Haymitch at 16 was the biggest risk here. It is also the part of the movie almost nobody is complaining about.

The Hollywood Reporter's David Rooney wrote that "the surprise asset here is Australian actor Joseph Zada in a breakout performance." Slashfilm's Nina Starner, who gave the film 8 out of 10, said "Zada sells every second as Haymitch." TheWrap's William Bibbiani praised how he suggests Harrelson's Haymitch without copying him: "Zada evokes, impressively, without resorting to imitation." Even Bleeding Cool's Kaitlyn Booth, who had real reservations, put it bluntly: "Any reason this movie works is because of Joseph Zada."

New faces in old roles

Ralph Fiennes takes over President Snow from the late Donald Sutherland. Bibbiani called it "a soulful performance," and Slant's Justin Clark wrote that Fiennes "brings an amoral coldness" to the part. Jesse Plemons, as a younger Plutarch Heavensbee, gets praise even from unhappy critics: The Daily Beast's Nick Schager, no fan of the film, wrote that Plemons "at least strikes a resonant chord." Kieran Culkin's Caesar Flickerman splits the room. Gleiberman found him "fine, but not nearly as stylishly depraved as Stanley Tucci."

Where the reviews split

The arena

In the book, the Second Quarter Quell doubles the field to 48 tributes, and the arena is where the positive reviews get most specific. Rooney called the arena action "vicious and bloody," and Booth thought the deaths "might be the most brutal ones in the series so far," which is worth knowing for a PG-13 movie. Bibbiani was taken with the look of the place: "it looks like Midsommar and Bambi had a lovechild." Not everyone felt the violence, though. Next Best Picture's Lauren LaMagna, who loved Zada, still found "a substantial lack of action and violence."

The 158 minutes

It runs a minute longer than Ballad and still has to cut. Starner noted that it "packs 400 pages into about 2 hours and 40 minutes." Schager was harsher: "Trying to stuff most of Collins' tome into 158 minutes, Lawrence's film shortchanges everything." Lawrence has said in interviews that his changes from the book are mostly about pacing, compressing the run-up to the Games and the aftermath.

Does Panem have anything left to say?

The harshest reviews are really about the franchise. "It's clear that the series has exhausted every point it ever wanted to make," wrote Alonso Duralde at The Film Verdict. Screen's Tim Grierson called it "an origin story without a sense of grandeur or stakes." The New York Times' Brandon Yu wrote that "Sunrise manages to be both bloated and limited," and The Guardian's Peter Bradshaw gave it one star and called it "surreally boring."

The other camp is just as sure. Little White Lies' Anna Stafford wrote that it "proves that the franchise still has plenty to say." Time Out's Phil de Semlyen gave it four stars and called it "far stronger than so many fished-from-the-bin franchise revivals." Rooney saw "a return, after the disappointing Songbirds and Snakes, to the spirit of the first movies," and Bibbiani went furthest of anyone: "it may even be the Hunger Games that holds up best."

Staying for the credits? You do not need to. Slashfilm confirms there is no mid-credits or post-credits scene in Sunrise on the Reaping.

Should you see it this weekend?

If you read the book, yes. RogerEbert.com's Matt Zoller Seitz, whose review Metacritic scores at 88, wrote of longtime fans that "they'll appreciate this movie for not lying to them," and most of the positive reviews say a version of the same thing. If the series lost you after Catching Fire, the reviews give you less reason to come back. The praise is for performances and craft, and the complaints are about familiarity.

Plenty of people are going regardless. Deadline reported on November 6 that presales were running ahead of Wicked and put the opening floor at $80 million or more, already far past the $44.6 million Ballad opened to in 2023. The first audience grades arrive Friday night. For the full cast and who played each role before, see our Sunrise on the Reaping guide, and for everything else opening, our weekend watch guide.

Poster for The Hunger Games: Catching Fire, showing Jennifer Lawrence as Katniss Everdeen
Image via TMDB

Then settle it yourself. Our Hunger Games movies ranked list has Catching Fire on top, and so do critics. On Shortlist you rank two at a time, so put Haymitch's Games up against Katniss's second trip into the arena and share the list with whoever you saw it with.

Frequently asked

Is Sunrise on the Reaping good?

Most critics say yes, with reservations. As of November 19, 2026, The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping holds 72 percent on Rotten Tomatoes from 107 reviews and is Certified Fresh, with a 55 on Metacritic from 32 critics. Reviewers widely praise Joseph Zada as young Haymitch Abernathy and split on the 158-minute runtime and on whether the franchise still has new ideas.

How does Sunrise on the Reaping rank against the other Hunger Games movies?

On Rotten Tomatoes, Sunrise on the Reaping (72 percent) ranks third of the six Hunger Games films, behind Catching Fire (90) and The Hunger Games (85) and ahead of both Mockingjay films (70 each) and The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes (64). On Metacritic its 55 ranks fifth, one point ahead of Ballad's 54.

Does Sunrise on the Reaping have a post-credits scene?

No. The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping has no mid-credits or post-credits scene, according to Slashfilm, so the movie is over once the credits start. The film is rated PG-13 and runs 2 hours 38 minutes.

Who plays young Haymitch in Sunrise on the Reaping?

Australian actor Joseph Zada plays 16-year-old Haymitch Abernathy in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, the role Woody Harrelson played as an adult in the original four films. The Hollywood Reporter's David Rooney called it a breakout performance.

Does Haymitch Beat Katniss?

Rank all six Hunger Games movies head to head on Shortlist, slot Sunrise on the Reaping in once you have seen it, and share the list with whoever you saw it with.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Reel

One sharp movie newsletter, every Tuesday

What to watch, what to skip, and where it lands on the rankings. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.