Critics Say Johnny Depp Is the Problem With Ebenezer. Opening-Night Audiences Gave It an A-.
Ti West's A Christmas Carol sits at 53 percent on Rotten Tomatoes, and most of the complaints are about its star. Ticket buyers disagreed and made it Friday's No. 1. Here is where the reviews split, and who should go.

Ebenezer opened on Friday, and its two report cards could hardly look less alike. Critics give Ti West's take on A Christmas Carol 53 percent on Rotten Tomatoes from 117 reviews and a 46 on Metacritic. Opening-night audiences gave it an A- CinemaScore, and Paramount's film took $7.1 million on Friday, including $1.5 million from Thursday previews, enough to knock Godzilla Minus Zero out of the top spot for the day.
Read the reviews and one name keeps coming up, and it is the one on the poster. Here is where critics landed, what nearly all of them liked, and whether you should bring the kids.
The scorecard
- Rotten Tomatoes: 53 percent from 117 reviews as of Saturday morning.
- Metacritic: 46 from 37 critics, with 8 positive, 21 mixed and 8 negative reviews.
- CinemaScore: A-, from audiences polled on opening night.
- PostTrak: 4.5 out of 5 stars, per World of Reel.
- The basics: rated PG-13 for frightening material, 1 hour 56 minutes, written by Nathaniel Halpern, with Ian McKellen as Marley, Rupert Grint as Bob Cratchit and Tramell Tillman as the Ghost of Christmas Present.
Make your tier list right here
Five films, head-to-head. Tap the one you prefer and we will build your order, then label it S through D.
Which do you prefer?
Tap your favorite
The Reel
Get this in your inbox every Tuesday
You are reading The Reel, Shortlist's weekly movie brief. One email a week, free, unsubscribe in one click.
The problem, according to critics: Depp
The most common complaint is the star. IndieWire's David Ehrlich gave the film a C- under a headline calling Depp "insufferable." Looper's Alistair Ryder used the same word and added that Depp "plays every line with a broadness that seems to treat the material as a long gag." IGN's Tom Jorgensen, one of the kinder voices with a 60, still found Depp's "overtheatrical take on Scrooge" out of step with the more grounded film around him. Screen Daily's headline called him a "cartoonish Scrooge."
He has defenders. Nick Schager of The Daily Beast scored it 77 and called the film "a do-over that earns [Depp] a measure of redemption, much like his iconic character." Variety's Guy Lodge and The Hollywood Reporter's Frank Scheck both found the performance solid, and The Telegraph's Robbie Collin was among the most positive critics, at 80.
What almost everyone liked: West's London

Even the pans tend to praise the look. Richard Roeper gave it three stars out of four and called it "a great-looking film with terrific production design, sound and cinematography." Ryder, who scored it 4 out of 10, wrote that West's "realization of mid-19th century London is admirably oppressive," a city where snow "lines the streets yet never falls." Bloody Disgusting's headline summed up the split: gothic atmosphere, "but little else."
Matt Zoller Seitz of RogerEbert.com, at 63, found more than atmosphere: "It has a measured tone and steady pace. It's funny and sometimes touching." The ensemble earns credit too. Ryder thanks "the amiable attempts of Tillman and the other overqualified members of the ensemble" for keeping the film afloat.
The argument nobody expected: is Scrooge right?
West told The A.V. Club in August that he wanted a grayer Scrooge than the usual villain. "We want to give Scrooge logic and a good argument, so when he is making an argument about something, he's not wrong," he said.
Not every critic bought it. Ryder argued that the film has "a pro-business attitude that counters the humanity of Dickens' novel," and pointed to a change that will surprise anyone who knows the book: the gentlemen collecting for charity are, in his words, "really just keeping the money to buy luxury items for themselves." If you go, that scene is the one to argue about on the drive home.
Why audiences graded it higher
Critics judged Ebenezer against a very crowded shelf. The Wall Street Journal's Kyle Smith wrote that it "sets itself up for a charge of being superfluous that it can't answer," and even Alonso Duralde of The Film Verdict, who liked it, wrote that it "isn't a Christmas Carol that changes the Christmas Carol game in any significant way."
Opening-night ticket buyers were grading a simpler question: was this a good night out in mid-November? An A- says yes. Depp still has a following, and this is his first studio lead in years, a role Variety reported he took for a $5 million fee. French audiences, who got the film on Wednesday, have rated it well too, per World of Reel.
The box office
Deadline projects an opening weekend of more than $20 million from that $7.1 million Friday, which its box office editor, Anthony D'Alessandro, put around where Depp's Black Mass ($22.6 million) and Public Enemies ($25.2 million) started. Paramount expects about $20 million more from 63 overseas markets. The reported production budget is $38 million, with roughly $50 million more spent on marketing.
If the projection holds, Ebenezer will be Depp's first No. 1 opening since Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald led with $62.2 million in November 2018, his last major studio film before this one. Godzilla Minus Zero was a strong No. 2 on Friday after its record first weekend, while David Leitch's How to Rob a Bank managed only $900,000 in Thursday previews, per World of Reel.
Should you bring the kids?
Take the PG-13 seriously. Scheck wrote in The Hollywood Reporter that this may be the first version of the story that is not for young children, and Eddie Harrison of film-authority.com called it a poor pick for families with kids under 12.
Seeing it with a younger crowd? The Muppet Christmas Carol (G), with Michael Caine as Scrooge, is still the gentlest version on the shelf. Our Ebenezer preview lists five older Scrooges and where to stream them.
Should you see it?
If you liked West's X and Pearl, or you simply want a handsome, wintry Christmas Carol on a big screen, the reviews give you real reasons to go: the production design, the cinematography and the supporting cast are the consensus picks. If Depp's late-career mannerisms wear on you, the critics' warning is specific and consistent, and it is about the man in nearly every frame.
Then settle it yourself. Add Ebenezer to Shortlist and rank it head to head against the Scrooges it is chasing: Alastair Sim in Scrooge (1951), Michael Caine in The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992) and Jim Carrey in Robert Zemeckis's A Christmas Carol (2009). For what else is coming this season, our Christmas movies of 2026 guide has every new holiday release, and the movie tier list guide shows how to sort a whole season at once.
Frequently asked
Is Ebenezer (2026) good?
Critics are split. As of November 14, 2026, Ti West's Ebenezer holds 53 percent on Rotten Tomatoes from 117 reviews and a 46 on Metacritic from 37 critics. Reviewers widely praise its gothic London, production design and supporting cast, and most of the complaints are about Johnny Depp's broad performance as Scrooge.
What CinemaScore did Ebenezer get?
Ebenezer earned an A- CinemaScore from opening-night audiences on November 13, 2026, and 4.5 out of 5 stars on PostTrak, per World of Reel. That is a much warmer reception than its 53 percent from critics on Rotten Tomatoes.
How much did Ebenezer make on its opening weekend?
Ebenezer made $7.1 million on Friday, November 13, 2026, including $1.5 million from Thursday previews, and was No. 1 for the day. Deadline projected an opening weekend of more than $20 million. The film's reported production budget is $38 million, and Paramount expects about $20 million from 63 overseas markets.
Is Ebenezer OK for kids?
Ebenezer is rated PG-13 for frightening material and runs 1 hour 56 minutes. Several critics, including The Hollywood Reporter's Frank Scheck, say it is too scary for young children. For families with kids under 12, The Muppet Christmas Carol, rated G, is a gentler Scrooge.
Depp, Sim or Caine?
Rank every Scrooge head to head on Shortlist, slot Ebenezer in once you have seen it, and share the list with whoever you saw it with.
The Reel
One sharp movie newsletter, every Tuesday
What to watch, what to skip, and where it lands on the rankings. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.
