ReviewNovember 11, 20266 min read

Rings of Power Season 3 Is the Show's Lowest on Rotten Tomatoes and Its Best on Metacritic. Critics Agree on Sauron.

Prime Video's Middle-earth series jumps five years and sends Sauron to war with the Elves. The first four episodes are out today. Here is what critics praise, what still bothers them, when the rest arrives, and whether to start.

The One Ring, a gold band etched with glowing script, resting on dark cracked stone flecked with embers, in key art for The Rings of Power
Image via The Movie Database (TMDB)

The Rings of Power is back. Prime Video released the first four episodes of season 3 on Wednesday, November 11, the show's first new episodes since 2024, and this season the story finally reaches the war: Sauron is fighting the Elves and hunting for the secret to forging the One Ring.

The reviews landed a day earlier with a strange split. On Rotten Tomatoes, season 3 has the lowest score of the show's three seasons. On Metacritic, it has the highest. Both are true at once, and the reason tells you a lot about whether you will like it. Here is the scorecard, what critics agree on, and whether to press play tonight.

The scorecard

  • Rotten Tomatoes: 79 percent from 29 reviews as of November 11, down from 84 percent for season 1 and 85 percent for season 2. The number moved all through the first day, with early tallies in the low 70s.
  • Metacritic: 73 from 11 critics, which counts as generally favorable: seven positive reviews, four mixed and none negative. Seasons 1 and 2 scored 71 and 67, per Dark Horizons, so this is the best of the three.
  • Audiences: Too early for season 3. Across the whole series, the Rotten Tomatoes Popcornmeter averages 48 percent from more than 25,000 ratings, against 82 percent from critics.
  • The catch: Critics were sent seven of the eight episodes, so nobody has reviewed the finale.

Make your tier list right here

Five Middle-earth films, head-to-head. Tap the one you prefer and we will build your order, then label it S through D.

Which do you prefer?

VS

Tap your favorite

The Reel

Get this in your inbox every Tuesday

You are reading The Reel, Shortlist's weekly movie brief. One email a week, free, unsubscribe in one click.

Why the two scores disagree

Rotten Tomatoes counts how many reviews are positive. Metacritic averages how positive they are. A lower share of fresh reviews alongside a higher average is the signature of a season that divides critics without angering them: fewer are fully on board, but the ones who are tend to be enthusiastic, and the holdouts mostly land on "mixed" rather than "bad." Metacritic did not count a single negative review.

In plain terms, critics are not split on whether season 3 is competent. They are split on whether a better version of this show is enough.

What season 3 is about

The story jumps forward five years. Sauron (Charlie Vickers) is waging the War of the Elves and Sauron from Barad-dûr while he hunts for the secret to the One Ring, and the few places still holding out include Khazad-dûm, Númenor and the Elven realms of Lindon and Rivendell. Showrunners J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay have called him a "full-on villain" this time.

Around him, per Screen Rant's review, Galadriel (Morfydd Clark) and Arondir (Ismael Cruz Córdova) set out to rescue an Elven smith, Durin IV (Owain Arthur) faces a succession fight in Khazad-dûm, Pharazôn (Trystan Gravelle) and Míriel (Cynthia Addai-Robinson) keep circling each other in Númenor, and Gandalf (Daniel Weyman) is still wandering in Rhûn.

An armored figure in a spiked crown stands with soldiers before a burning orange sky on the poster for The Rings of Power season 3
Image via TMDB

The new faces: Jamie Campbell Bower as Celeborn, Galadriel's long-lost husband; Eddie Marsan as Thráin; Adam Young as Marnûkh, a mysterious Orc who gives the premiere its title; and Simon Pegg as the voice of the Balrog, which speaks for the first time.

What critics praise

Sauron, finally unleashed

If one thing unites the reviews, it is Vickers. Nerdist's Rotem Rusak, who calls this "the best season of the show so far," writes that Vickers "absolutely crushes it as a Sauron who is at once SO evil and SO pathetic and SO fabulous and SO needy." Even CBR, whose review says the season's epic war falls frustratingly flat, singles out Vickers' Sauron as its bright spot.

A tighter story

Screen Rant's Graeme Guttmann gives it 8 out of 10 and calls the season "leaner, meaner, and much more gratifying than any of its predecessors," arguing that "with Sauron so focused on one singular goal, the series itself feels lasered in on its own goal." Radio Times' Louise Griffin agrees it has "a tighter and more interesting narrative."

The look, and a few new favorites

Slashfilm's Jeremy Mathai gives it only 5 out of 10 and still says the show "has never looked better nor felt more cinematic." That is the payoff of what Mathai calls the most expensive series on streaming. Season 1 alone reportedly cost about $465 million. Decider's Meghan O'Keefe calls it "proudly an idiosyncratic, raucous, nerdy, and extremely metal show," Mathai names Marnûkh "easily one of the season's best new additions," and Rusak calls Sophia Nomvete's stone singing as Disa "a true highlight."

What still bothers them

  • Too many plots. Mathai counts "too many far-flung locations to check in on, too many main characters," and GamesRadar+ headlines its review "Sauron is unleashed, but this fantasy show is still tangled in dense subplots." Its critic, Molly Edwards, calls the court scheming "Game of Thrones-lite."
  • The writing. Forbes' Erik Kain finds the script "weighed down by its unearned gravitas," and RogerEbert.com's Lacy Baugher says the show "no longer feels confident about what it's trying to say."
  • Gandalf. Guttmann, one of the season's fans, says the Rhûn storyline still feels tacked on. IndieWire's Ben Travers calls Gandalf "little more than a mysterious symbol."
  • The Jackson shadow. Polygon's Samantha Nelson writes that the show "is not going to change the world like Jackson's films," and singles out Númenor as its weakest stretch.

The Rings of Power season 3 release schedule

Season 3 has eight episodes, streaming only on Prime Video, in three drops:

  • Episodes 1 to 4: Wednesday, November 11 (out now): "Marnûkh," "The Gift of Men," "The Secret Fire" and "Gundabad"
  • Episodes 5 and 6: Wednesday, November 18
  • Episodes 7 and 8: Wednesday, November 25, the night before Thanksgiving

Should you start season 3?

Our take, from the reviews: if Sauron was your favorite part of the first two seasons, start tonight, because this is the season built around him. If you quit over the pacing, the four episodes out now are a fair test, since critics say it is tighter but the old habits remain. New to the show? The premiere opens with a prologue recapping the war, and the showrunners say newcomers can start here. Griffin is skeptical, so a season 2 recap first will not hurt.

Then settle it. Add The Rings of Power to Shortlist and rank it head to head against House of the Dragon and Game of Thrones, two at a time, until you know where it really lands. Our TV show tier list guide shows how to sort the whole list, and our Lord of the Rings movies ranked list covers Peter Jackson's films and the animated ones that came before. We first flagged the premiere in this week's weekend watch guide, before the reviews were in.

Frequently asked

Is The Rings of Power season 3 good?

Critics are mostly positive, with reservations, and several call it the show's best season. As of November 11, 2026, season 3 holds 79 percent on Rotten Tomatoes from 29 reviews, the lowest of the three seasons, and a 73 on Metacritic from 11 critics, the highest of the three, with no negative reviews. Charlie Vickers' Sauron and the tighter story draw the most praise, while too many subplots and overwrought writing draw the most complaints.

When do new episodes of The Rings of Power season 3 come out?

Season 3 has eight episodes on Prime Video. Episodes 1 to 4 premiered on Wednesday, November 11, 2026. Episodes 5 and 6 arrive on Wednesday, November 18, and the final two episodes arrive on Wednesday, November 25, 2026.

Who is new in The Rings of Power season 3?

Jamie Campbell Bower joins as Celeborn, Galadriel's long-lost husband. Eddie Marsan plays Thráin, Adam Young plays a mysterious Orc named Marnûkh, and Simon Pegg voices the Balrog, which speaks for the first time in the series.

Can you start The Rings of Power with season 3?

The showrunners, J.D. Payne and Patrick McKay, say newcomers can start with season 3, which jumps five years after season 2 and opens with a prologue recapping the war between Sauron and the Elves. Some critics, including Radio Times' Louise Griffin, are skeptical, so a quick recap of seasons 1 and 2 helps.

Where does The Rings of Power rank for you?

Rank it head to head against House of the Dragon and the rest of your fantasy shows on Shortlist, then share your TV tier list before the November 25 finale.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

The Reel

One sharp movie newsletter, every Tuesday

What to watch, what to skip, and where it lands on the rankings. Free, no spam, unsubscribe anytime.